Libron's ministry of llute and tender appetizer Aliu is in danger of taking the country by surprise

Kosovars are getting very lucky that they are not holding frost yet. Whether it snowed yesterday, today, or even during the coming days in Pristina, Prizren, Gjilan or Mitrovica, and some other countries, regional and regional roads would remain blocked. That's because there are no companies contracted for their maintenance.

On April 11th 2022, the Ministry of Infrastructure opened tenders for good roads maintenance. After a few days, MMPHI corrected the tender file and the requested equipment list because it did not proceed in harmony with the Public Procuration Law. In September he announced the winner. Some companies have complained that the law was violated when the bidding assessment was made. The ministry has acknowledged that it has made illegal assessments, at least in five contracts and overturned its decision, and then recommended other companies for the contract. Again, there have been complaints, and the ministry has dropped them and then companies are heading to the OSHP.

In the tender “The summer and winter maintenance of national and regional roads 2022 -2025“, the projected value of contracts is 30 921 000,00 euros for three years, and the companies that have been racing are not few, but 28 Sosh.

In September, the ministry recommended contracting these companies and company groups:

Pristina - 1. “”via” shpk, Eurokos Holding”, “A. L - Asphalest” shpk, “Dio Bes” shpk, “Eurotitan” shpk. Value in a year of 617, 047. 26 euros.

Pristina two. “Rahovica” shpk, “Quality Asphalt” shpk, “Eurotrans” shpk, “Iridian” shpk, “Corsel shpk, “J -Import expert Doo Kavadar<10> Value in a year 507, 698. 35.

Pristina - 3 “AAB Construction” shpk, N. N.P. “ndering”, “Urban O. P”, “Adnan BI”, “Premium-x” shpk. The value for a year of 484, 574.20 euros.

Mitrovica 1. “Arbotec” shpk. Value in one year 527, 553. 34 euros.

Mitrovica -2. RINDER, absent responsible offers.

Five. One. “Ex-Fix” shpk. Value in a year 659, 230. 60 euros.

Peja -2. “Graniti” shpk. The value for a year of 658, 202.02 euros.

Prizren-1. “Damastion Project” shpk. Value of 497, 250. 29 euros.

Prizren -2. “Famis Co-HC” chess. Value in a year 594, 257. 83 euros.

Ferizaj -1. “via” shpk, “Eurocos Holding”, “A. L Asphalt” KPS, “Dio Bes” KPS, “Euroitani” shpk. The value for a year of 497, 079.20 euros.

Ferizaj -2. “Damastion Project” shpk. Value in a year 464, 034. 67 euros.

Gilani -1. “El-Bau” shpk, “Gan Logistic” shpk, “ER-Lis”, shpk, “Limon Staneci P. N” Value in a year 479, 575. 34 euros.

Gjilan -2. “via Egnatia”, “Humolli -S -Perol”, shpk, “VJV Group”. A year's worth of 652, 327.77 euros.

I got blood. “Value in a year of 635, 267. 03 euros.

I'm bleeding two. “RSM Company” shpk. Value in one year 470, 105. 98 euros.

After the winnings were released, Periscope had reported that some of the companies recommended for the contract had been irresponsible in the past and that Deputy Prime Minister Hysen Dumrish himself had invited the prosecution for Investigations.

Also recommended for the contract were Hysen Dumrish dot company, Bujar Shaban, owner of the company “Bager”.

So, as seen, for the “Partin 3”, Kosovo was recommended for contract “Asphat” shpk, “AAB Construction” shpk, N. N.P. “Construction”, “Urban O. P”, “Adnan BI”, “Premium-ks” shpk. The leader of the group who has claimed responsibility “Kosovo Asphalt”, owned by Valdrin Shabani, Bujar's son, the last one in the prime minister, Dumrish.

“Pristina -1” has won the group” via” shpk, Eurokos Holding”, “A. L - Asphalest” shpk, “Dio Bes” shpk, “Euro-European” shpk. Value in a year of 617, 047. 26 euros. Although not the group's leader, the company “Dio Bes” is owned by Jedal Shabani, son of Bujar Shaban's brother, and Xhelal was manager of the company “Bager”.

Ministry does not allow companies access to winning bid

Companies that had cheaper prices and who disagreed with the ministry's decision on the reasons for eliminating the race had sought access to the documentation of companies recommended for the contract.

Periscop has reported that the minister has allowed partial access to some of the offers, While in the company's bid “Kosovo Asfalt” has allowed no access to documentation at all. Even in those offers where the ministry has allowed access to documentation, it has allowed only part of the documents to be seen, hiding key documents dealing with technical and financial capacity. It turns out that some companies have sought access to documentation, and none of them have been given full documentation.

Ministry extended the currency of illegal bids

However, many companies have managed to file timely complaints at the ministry. During the period when the bids have been in re-evaluation, the ministry has charged the document with e-procurement that concerns extending the wave of bids.

Secondary Public Procureing Legislation (Rules and Operational Guide for Public Procurement) at Article 31 has preceded the Tender Validity. According to this article, contracting authorities should check the tender file for the required tender value period and specified as the number of calendar days from the deadline for the tenders' delivery. In this case, the ministry has written that the bidding rate is 90 days.

It can change the complexity of the tender depending on it. So the contracting authority can submit additional time to companies for the duration of currency, but it has to send documentation for compliance without expired.

Periscop saw that, the procurement manager had asked economic operators to extend the wave eight days after it expired. In such cases, the procurement organization had completely canceled the procurement process for contracting authorities.

Ministry admits violation, turned part of the tender into re-evaluation

After the bids were held several weeks in re-evaluation, the ministry came out with new announcements. In October, the MMPHI procurement office admitted it had committed legal violations when it recommended contract to companies for five tears of this tender. This approval of the violation, the ministry has made it in demand for reviews that 16 contestants had made.

Therefore, the procurement decided that five parts of Thank you. Once again, he admitted to making legal concessions.

The ministry has made a statement when it recommended the contract with Deputy Prime Minister Hysen Durmish, who was authorized for the “Prishtina -3” contract, where the companies “Kosovo Asfat” shpk, “AAB Construction” shpk, N. N.P. “ndering”, “Urban O. P”, “Adnan BI”, “Premium-ks” shpk. The value for a year of 484, 574.20 euros, or for three years, 1m and 375 thousand euros. Owner of company leader “Kosovo Asphalt” is owned by Bujar Shaban's son, Hysen Durmish's dost.

Besides this part of the tender “Pristina 2”, the ministry made the decision to cancel its decision and return to a part of the tender “Pristina -2” where companies have been recommended for contract at the subset “Rahovica” shpk, “Qualty Asphalt<7> shpk, <x> <x>c>, “>, “ > Korsel shpk, “Here's my expert.

Also, in the reassession, “Pristina -1” where”Va” shpk, Eurokos Holding”, “A. L - Asphalest” shpk, “Dio Bes” shpk, “Euro-European” shpk.

The ministry has acknowledged that it has committed violations even when recommending for contract “Peja 1” where “Alco Impex - General Construction”, shpk, “Ex-Fix” shpk.

Also, “Gylani -2” where they were recommended for contract “via Egnatia”, “Humolli -S -Perol”, shpk, “VJV Group” A year's worth of 652, 327.77 euros.

The ministry has not indicated what the violations it has committed, namely the conditions that have not met companies when they are recommended for the contract, but only said concessions have been made.

“MMPHI as contracting authority after accepting the application has reviewed the validity of all complaint parties claims. MMPHI, during reviewing the complaints of economic operators, notes that several concessions have been made to the OE group -- recommended for the contract -- at Pristina 1, Pristina 2 and Pristina 3. So based on complaints, and noting them during the review, the MMPHI decides that tears 1.2.3 and Pristina 1, 2, 3 subject will be returned to Revaluation”, it is said in the complaint that has been approved to the group of complaining companies.

The other 13 subjects that have been companies in the consortium, but as the only ones whose complaints have been rejected by the ministry, have been directed to the Procuration Research Organisation.

O Experts Double - Standard Explices

Right after O The E.P. had accepted the complaints, had authorised two experts to sift the evidence and then hand over their report to say the final word at a session, the Board of Procuration Research.

Periscop has a copy of this report, and it turns out that engaged experts have been, Ilir Halili and Wisar Basha. He had drafted the expertise report for the summer and winter maintenance tender of two Kosovo highways. Although, there was no board of O The EPS to address that report, he had rejected all complaints from companies and had left the decision of the contractor Authority, which was signed by Nexhat Krasniqi. Periscop has reported that tender has been completed for investigation into the economic crimes police, which Mr. Basha will likely be investigated.

According to the report that these two experts have submitted, it is confirmed that the Accounting Authority has violated the screening deadline for review, not assessing bids within the deadline, concealing and documents contrary to LPP Article 11.

And also, it was the claim of the complaining companies, the procedural violation that leads to the annulment of procurement activity: Do not continue the bidding currency deadline, which according to the KCPP no contract can be signed with expired currency.

However, experts on the matter have suggested that it also comes from KCPP performance, refusing to cancel the activity, saying that nowhere does it say the procurement activity needs to be cancelled.

Access and other thought, in terms of the tenders' assessment, do not continue to collect and secure bids, expert Visar Basha has another procurement activity.

He's on the rapporteur. No. 216/20, 218/20 where for the same circumstances, he has insisted on canceling the procurement activity because of these violations, since there is no currency of bids, no deadlines to assess offers have been respected, no tender insurance.

The same had also proposed to the review panel that measures be taken against responsible officials of the contracting authority.

And in regional and regional road maintenance expertise, regarding claims of taking measures against procurement officials, says” are out of the competence of the examiner's expert, and eventually the review panel can consider”.

In CRPP Web site update, it's question 7.22.11.2022 on bid currency while the subject is under consideration in O The E.P.

Even during this O review period The times, the bids continue to be unvalipated, and without tender insurance.

The expert is positioned for the VV funder and chief procurement Homie

Whatever the case, these two experts have dismissed Prizren 1, Gjilani 1, Pristina 2, Mitrovica 2, where it recommended that the ministry's decision remain in force, and has demanded that Gjilan 2 and Pristina become re-evaluated.

The tender was initiated by procurement manager Nexhat Krasniqi. He had also appointed the evaluation commission for bids and later the ministry had removed him from the chief's position to appoint Ndzicim Mustafa. After the first complaints, the bidding assessment commission had appointed Mustafa and had found violations in five cases of contract recommendation, where he had later changed the companies.

If on four other occasions, this commission had removed companies from the competition at the consortium “Alco Impex - General Construction”, shpk, “Ex-Fix” shpk for the Peja 1.

Now, when he has returned as procurement manager, Nexhat Krasniqi, O experts The EPS has decided to only approve two complaints, one of them is “Alco Impex - General Construction”, shpk, “Ex-Fix” The “Alko Mimix” is owned by Imer Ademi, who is the father of Valon Ademi, the last best friend to the procurement manager, Valon Ademi. While the company in conzeroum “Ex-Fix”, which has nothing to do with maintenance of roads because it only deals with oil derivatives, is a self-Determination Movement's letter funder. It has also been dismissed in complaints involving one of the tears in which the Zv Homies company has been recommended for contract. Durmish.

It remains to be seen when the O board will make decision The DS for this tender, as it is under time pressure. If the board is to make a decision to cancel the process as a whole, then it would force the ministry to link emergency contracts where specific companies, as has happened in the past, because it does not have time to launch an open value tender. The board will also be under pressure to grant access to the ministry as well, because we are ready in winter, a decision that will then leave space for the investigation to be levelled. So, all the pressure, the ministry has left to the OSHP Board, and the ministry would be pleased that this board made its decision very quickly, whatever it is. /M. B - PERISCOP/