Appeal confirms the liberation of the two accused for help in the 2021 serious murder

In this case, the two indictees, along with Valdrin Halimin, were charged with the murder case of the E.R., due to the 250-euro debt. Concretically, Halimi was charged with “grave murder”, “withholding unauthorized possession of weapons”, and with unauthorized possession of narcotics, psychotopal substances or analogo”. While Nuredin was charged with the “Unauthorized possession of narcotics, psychotopic or analogo” and, likewise, with the accused Idrizi was charged with carrying out criminal work in co-ordination “contributed to the carrying out of the criminal offense --”.

“is rejected as unequivocal complaint by the DKR Attorney in Gjilan, and the DKR Constitutional Court Act in Gjilan, PKR.23/25 of the 1808.2025, confirmed. The complaint of the authorized representative of the damaged A. R., H. R., A. S. and B. K., av. Skender Musa, dismissed as illegal”, says the Apel decision compiled on April 22nd, 2026, reports “Justice Trust”.

The Constitutional Court in Gjilan, in the retrial, with the indictment of August 18th 2025, has acquitted accused Erdony Nuredini and Rabbi Idrizi of criminal work “of assisting in carrying out the criminal offence of serious murder”.

Against this act, the prosecution has filed a complaint with the Constitutional Prosecutor in Gjilan, claiming in substantial violation of criminal procedure provisions, mistaken and incomplete confirmation of the actual situation, as well as violation of the Criminal Law. The prosecution has demanded that Appeals change the sentence and declare the guilty or cancel it and turn the case into retrial.

Ankee has also presented the authorized representative of the damaged A.R., H.R., A.S. and B.C., attorney Skender Musa, with a request for changing his bias or annulment.

Defenders of the accused, lawyers Ardit Latifi (for Erdonys Nuredin) and Milot Spahiu (For Rabbi Idriz) have rejected complaints as groundless and have sought confirmation of the liberation trial.

The Court of Appeals, in the college consisting of President Valbona Musliu-Selimaj and members Dzevdet Abazi and Kadrije Goga-Lubishani, have found that the Constitutional Prosecutor's complaint in Gjilan is not based, while the complaint of authorised representatives of damaged parties is unfair.

Appeal estimates that the act of the Constitutional Court is clear, concrete, and contains sufficient reasons for crucial facts.

According to Appeal, the Court of the First Scale in a fair and complete way has proven the actual situation based on the evidence prosecuted during the trial review the statements of witnesses A. R., H. R., A. S., B. K., as well as his statements to indictees Nuredini and Idrizi, along with material evidence such as ballistic expertise reports, autopsy report, initials, the site's sketches, the recontamination report and other data.

Appeals finds that with administered evidence it has not been proven that accused Erdonys Nuredini and Rabbi Idrizi have committed any incriminating acts that would provide help in carrying out the criminal act of serious murder.

The court stresses that the accused had no knowledge that Valdrin Halimi possessed firearms or that he had gone deliberately to deprive the late E.R. of life now. And that verbal confrontation and gun shooting happened away from the vehicle where Nuredini and Idriz were.

The Appeals Court estimates that after committing criminal acts by Valdrin Halimi, who has been convicted of “grave murders in overcoming the necessary defence”, the accused have received the wounded Halim and sent to Gjilan Hospital to provide first aid, thus performing the task of providing assistance to the injured person.

The appeal re-exemplifies that the first-degree court has acted in accordance with the principle of presumption of innocence and the principle in dubio pro reo, stressing that the burden of evidence belongs to the Prosecutor and that any doubt concerning the existence of elements of the criminal act should be interpreted in favour of the accused.

Otherwise, the Constitutional Court in Gjilan with the conviction of November 8, 2024, has convicted Valdrin Halimin and sentenced him to a unique sentence of 12 years in prison and 500 euros in fines for serious murder in overstepping the necessary protection, illegal possession and possession of narcotics. Erdonys Nuredini was sentenced to 1 year and 6 months in prison and 800 euros in fines for narcotics possession. Nuredini and Rabbi Idrizi were acquitted of helping him commit a serious murder.

While the Court of Appeals has confirmed the sentences to Valdrin Halim and Erdonys Nuredini on March 7th verdict, but has cancelled the release to Nuredin and Rabbi Idriz for help in serious murder, turning the case into a retrial in the Constitutional Court.

In the retrial, with the decision of August 18th 2025, the Foundation acquitted accused Erdonys Nuredini and Rabbi Idrizi, on the grounds that they have not proven to have committed the burdened criminal work.

In contrast, according to the indictment compiled on May 26th 2022 by Gjilan's Founding Prosecutor, defendant Valdrin Halimi on November 8th 2021 around 20:40, in the district “Arberia” in Gjilan, near the home of now late E.R, with direct action, has deliberately deprived the deceased E's life now, with the aim of gaining wealth in many of 250 euros, where the same village of Pogra Pogra starts in the direction of the late Gulf with the intent that 250 (the euro now felt to the indictees of the Rabelini's car) and the former Rudinidinitinda Hudinid Golf II” that defendant Nuredini has directed.

The highlanders are said to arrive in front of the deceased's home, where defendant Valdrin comes out of the car meets with the same, offers himself next to him, puts his hand on his shoulder, and takes out the gun, which he now directs to the deceased in the vicinity, saying “. At this moment, according to the E.R. indictment, he enters the house, takes a gun, comes out, and immediately defendant Valdrin fires twice in his direction, and then the deceased fires five times in the direction of the defendants from a distance of 10 meters and from the gunshot and from the wounds taken in the chest, now the deceased cannot survive and in the hospital changes lives.

In this case, Halimi was charged with committing criminal work “grave murder”, by Article 173, par.1, ahead.1.5 and 1.6 of KPRK.

At the same time, the defendant Halimi in the country and the same date, without authorisation and contrary to the applicable law regarding weapons, has reportedly held the weapon possession of both the type "Zorakiʹ, with a charger and two bullets, which are seized by Kosovo police.

By what, it was alleged to have committed criminal work “ownership, control or unauthorized possession of weapons”, from Article 366, paragraph 1 of KPRK.

Furthermore, the indictment states that the accused Halimi, without authorization, possessed narcotics of marijuana, which was declared by law as dangerous narcotics, so that in late hours of the night in the village of Pigrage, Gjilan, during the search by police officials, in the <x0 car. Golf 2”, the speed changer, has been found and 1.9 grams of marijuana-type narcotics, a package of risillas, and a blinder for grinding narcotics.

In this case, the same one was charged with committing criminal work “Unauthorized possession of narcotics, psychotrope or analogo” by Article 269, par.1 related to par.3 of KPRK.

According to the indictment, defendant Nuredini, on November 8, 2021, without authorisation has possessed the narcotic substance of marijuana, which has been declared by law as dangerous narcotic, so that in the early morning hours of November 9, 2021, at the entrance of the village of Pogragea, in a meadow by police officials has been found and seized 10.5 grams of marijuana, which defendant Erdoonsie Nuredini had thrown.

For this, he was charged with committing criminal work “The unauthorized possession of narcotics, psychotrope or analogo” by Article 269, par.1 related to the KPRK's par.3.

The charge in the indictment is said to be the defendant Nuredini, along with Rabbi Idriz on November 8, 2021 around 20:40, in the neighborhood of “Arberia” of Gjilan, near the home of the now injured E.R., has helped defendant Valdrin Halimi, in the manner that the defendants Idriz and Erdonis Nuredini have known he communicated on the phone with the late President Valdrin Egen now in a car to help commit the criminal work.

In this case, the same were charged with co-ordination committing criminal work “assistance in carrying out the criminal offence of serious murder”, by Article 173, par.1, before. 1.5 and 1.6 regarding Article 31 and KPRK Article 33.