The expert's testimony at The Hague: Supportability and reliability in SPS transcripts is low

The expert's testimony at The Hague: Supportability and reliability in SPS transcripts is low

In their trial against Hashim Thaci, the Smajt Union, Isni Kilajt, Fadil Fazlius and Hajredin Kuci, in the case against justice administration, expert Helen Fraser said that the reliance on transcripts of the Specialised Prosecutor's Office (ZPS) by the audio visits to the Pre-burging Centre is low.

Initially, Thaci's defender, lawyer Sophie Menegon, said they have sought from Hysni Recica and a translation company transliterated part of Kilajt's visit from the Pre-burg Centre, reports the “Justice Trust“.

In a section of Recica's transcript, it is seen that the word “Vlaznim” is put red, while the translation company has made a part white, yet at first it says the same “Vlaznim”.

Fraser said that transcripts look similar.

As for another part of the audio, Recica says it is unclear and undesirable. The company, on the other hand, made a bleach with a few different words but few words. On the other hand, the SPS has broader transcripts.

There are many differences, audio has been less clear”, Fraser said.

According to her, transcriptors should have the ability to decipher unclear versions and follow a applicable methodology. He said the transcriptors had to translate independently without seeing comparisons.

As far as the reliability and credibility of the SPS transcripts are concerned, the expert said the support is low.

We cannot rely on them as correct transcripts for the” judicial process, Fraser said.

She said we don't have demonstrated ability to talk audio, and there is no particular methodology.

The expert said the lack of time stamps makes it difficult to evaluate transcripts and compare to a transcript or other translation.

Fraser added that the numerous use of punctuation signs makes the texts appear to be written rather than spoken. He said the punctuation marks on the transcript are minimal.

As for the audio from Smajt's visit, from the ZPS transcript, it is said that in one section it says “Artan Behrami imitates someone (undesirable)”, Fraser said that when you say “you're imitating the situation that the transliter/reformer has made.

She says that the SPS makes the protracted interpretation of the words and noises heard.

The lawyer said the prosecution has claimed that those involved in the transcript/translation to the case have also worked on the transcript/translation to the war crimes case.

Related
"Five friends from Kosovo went into the sea..." - All of what happened to the tragedy in Strygan where two young Kosovars died

"Five friends from Kosovo went into the sea..." - All of what happened to the tragedy in Strygan where two young Kosovars died

KOMF: Children are not a tool for promoting political subjects

KOMF: Children are not a tool for promoting political subjects

“cacanic waits, cachanic acts” Hamza with calls for a change from Kachanik

“cacanic waits, cachanic acts” Hamza with calls for a change from Kachanik

Albania loses Mara era, Israel wins in “Air Albania”

Albania loses Mara era, Israel wins in “Air Albania”

Analyst Blair Baraliu: Ardian Gjini is a brave and wise leader, Alliance with the potential to unlock political stalemate

Analyst Blair Baraliu: Ardian Gjini is a brave and wise leader, Alliance with the potential to unlock political stalemate

2 hours of protest in the boulevard against the Zrvenec project, citizens don't take rain away, call for revolution from the prime minister

2 hours of protest in the boulevard against the Zrvenec project, citizens don't take rain away, call for revolution from the prime minister

What documents are allowed voting? CEC Clears

What documents are allowed voting? CEC Clears

After the tragedy in Shengjin, Kosovo's ambassador to Albania visits survivors: They're in good shape.

After the tragedy in Shengjin, Kosovo's ambassador to Albania visits survivors: They're in good shape.

Six Premier League clubs after Barcelona's talent

Six Premier League clubs after Barcelona's talent

The show VV is avoiding these choices: Why does no one from Kurt's party dare argue with Dardan Krasniqi?

The show VV is avoiding these choices: Why does no one from Kurt's party dare argue with Dardan Krasniqi?

Ismaili: Kurti has turned crisis into governance and divisions into political tool

Ismaili: Kurti has turned crisis into governance and divisions into political tool

Storms Near Albania, Region

Storms Near Albania, Region

Elmi Recia publishes facts: How did the Kurti government block the Blackwater Impiant project in Ferizaj?

Elmi Recia publishes facts: How did the Kurti government block the Blackwater Impiant project in Ferizaj?